TAPE execs say GMA’s P37.9M estafa charge is mere case of ‘breach of contract’

TAPE and GMA logos. FILE PHOTO
TAPE Inc. executives Seth Frederick “Bullet” Jalosjos, Malou Choa-Fagar, Zenaida Buenavista and Michaela Magtoto submitted a joint counter-affidavit on the estafa complaint filed against them by GMA Network.
The respondents filed their counter-affidavit before the Office of the City Prosecutor in Quezon City on Tuesday, July 8, along with their legal counsel Maggie Abraham-Garduque.
Former TAPE president and CEO Romeo Jalosjos, Jr., and chairman Romeo Jalosjos, Sr., who are also named in GMA’s complaint, are set to submit their counter-affidavit on July 15.
“It has to be underscored here that the case is filed against Jalosjos, et. al, who are the members of the board and officers of TAPE Inc. However, it is their submission that they cannot be liable for the alleged liability of the corporation,” Abraham-Garduque said in a statement to Inquirer Entertainment. In the counter-affidavit, it is the submission of the respondents that they are not liable for a criminal case for estafa.”
The legal counsel noted that the assignment agreement was between TAPE Inc., the corporation, and GMA network.
“Under the law, a corporation has a separate and distinct personality from its stockholders. Since TAPE Inc. is a corporation, you cannot file a criminal case against a corporation,” she said.
She further pointed out that the source of the obligation is a contract, which is the assignment agreement.
“No other than our Supreme Court in its array of jurisprudence ruled that if an obligation arose from a contract then then there will be no estafa,” she noted.
“Lastly, in the demand letters of GMA attached to this complaint, they admitted that if no payment is made they will file a case for breach of contract or collection case against TAPE Inc. Therefore, GMA admitted that this case should be a civil case for breach of contract or collection case only and not criminal case for estafa,” Abrham-Garduque added.
GMA accused TAPE of estafa through abuse of confidence last May, alleging that the production company misused funds amounting to ₱37,941,352.56 for its operating expenses. /edv