Too many quirky cooks


Marvin Agustin’s new reality challenge show, “Karinderya Wars,” has just completed its third week of telecasts on TV5. How well is it faring, and who are the front-runners in its search for the best masa cook in the land?

Marvin himself is doing okay, providing just the right mix of experience, professionalism and inspiration that the “amateur” but experienced contenders need to get their act together and rise up to a higher level of culinary “performance.”

The nine finalists themselves are another case entirely, however. We must presume that all of them are veteran cooks, but some contenders get rattled by the rules and deadlines, and forget to buy such basic things as rice, salt and cooking oil!

Even worse, some of them are trying too hard to come across as quirky, sassy, colorful and combative characters—or, are they being encouraged or pressured by the show to be so?

Colorful characters

Whatever the reason, the gambit ends up generally rubbing viewers the wrong way. For one, they aren’t experienced actors, so their “colorful” characters come across as self-conscious and “TH.”

The show tries to create little feuds and backbiting contests to keep things “interesting,” but nobody is uniquely “quotable” enough to elicit genuine viewer interest and excitement. So, our advice to the feuding finalists is: Concentrate more on your cooking, why don’t you?

Another gambit that doesn’t really work is the “comic relief” ostensibly provided by Marvin’s three loud and livid “assistants,” who are either gay or “fag hag” in projection.

Their snitty and churlish kind of “comedy” provides little “relief,” and is generally just an unnecessary distraction.



Also rather disappointing is the way that the cooking has been done on the show thus far. Most of the time, the three teams of finalists have been left up to their own devices in thinking up the menu for the day. As a result, pretty much the same staple dishes are featured, and the cooking aspect of the tilt consequently comes off as rather cavalier.

Viewers would get more involved if, from time to time, all of the teams were required to cook the same special dish, and tasters or jurors were asked to share with the TV audience what makes one team’s version better than the others’.

Finally, the show should find a better way to handle its crowd of “eaters.” Usually, they have to be  dragged to the tables to partake of the menu for the day, and their “comments” are grudging or woefully inadequate—“masarap,” “maasim,”  “Okay  naman”—gee, thanks!

The proof of the pudding isn’t just in the eating but also in the describing, so the eaters have to be selected better, to boost that key aspect of the show.

With these and other improvements, we hope that “Karinderya Wars” will turn out to be a more involving and yummier viewing treat from here on in—so starvin’ Marvin and his show’s viewers can smile more and end each day’s TV feast with a loud and satisfied burp!

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Dan Valuz

    Nestor Torre, really is a keen observer and one of the best critics around. It is just too bad that so many people dont understand and appreciate what he “brings to the table.” A true critic like Nestor Torre, doesn’t have to prove himself to the “haters” and “attack dogs” sent from other newspapers to flood his page with stupid comments and below the belt attacks! These A-Holes try to discredit critics like Mr. Torre, and make him appear like he doesn’t know what he is saying when he knows very well the things he say. We salute you Nestor Torre for continuing to write the way you do.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94