Quantcast
Latest Stories

Local singers up against the ‘Phantom’ menace

By

JETT Pangan hopes Filipinos will support local productions, too.

Singer-actor Jett Pangan, the lead star of Atlantis’ new musical “Nine,” has added his voice to the campaign of local artists to impose proper dues on foreign productions like “The Phantom of the Opera.”

Pangan said foreign artists should pay P5,000 each pursuant to a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) signed in 1989 between the Bureau of Immigration (BI) and local artists groups, led by the Organisasyon ng Pilipinong Mangaawit (OPM) and the Asosasyon ng mga Musikong Pilipino (AMP).

“I support both the OPM and the Theater Actors Guild (TAG), which want the BI to honor the MOA on the Equity Rights Program,” said Pangan, who straddles both the music and theater scenes. “The equity dues will go to local artists’ welfare fund.”

Filipino singers, actors and musicians under the banner of the Alliance of Working Artists for Rights and Equity (Aware) have protested the decision of the BI to grant special working permits to the foreign cast and crew of “Phantom.”

Aware is an umbrella organization of artists that includes OPM, AMP, TAG and other groups raising this issue.

“I don’t agree that just because (the ‘Phantom’ stars) are theater actors, and not singers, they should be exempt from equity obligations,” Pangan asserted.

He explained that these foreign performers also sing onstage, adding that international productions compete for the same audience and sponsors as those of local shows.

However, the BI said the foreign cast of “Phantom” was issued a special work permit even without clearance from the OPM because it was not covered by an agreement between the agency and the local group.

CAST of “Nine”: (standing from left) Carla Guevara-Laforteza, Sitti Navarro, Jay Glorioso, Cherie Gil, Eula Valdez, Yanah Laurel, (seated from left) Ima Castro, Pangan and Menchu Lauchengco-Yulo

According to a statement released by BI spokesperson Ma. Antonette Mangrobang: “There is no basis for the bureau to require stage actors who are not singers or musicians to submit to the equity program.”

Mangrobang, in an earlier statement, explained that the MOA between the bureau and the OPM only applies to foreign singers, backup vocalists and instrumentalists.

 

Not fair

“Why should they be allowed to circumvent our laws?” asked Cherie Gil, another “Nine” star.  “They should pay the right taxes.”

Costar Carla Guevara-Laforteza, agreed: “It’s not fair. Filipino artists can’t perform abroad without paying all sorts of levies.”

Ima Castro, who is also in the cast of “Nine,” recounted that she dutifully paid taxes in the United Kingdom, where she played Kim in the musical “Miss Saigon” a decade ago.

“It was automatically deducted from my salary,” Castro recalled. “In a year, I paid a total of 6,000 pounds (or around P407,000 at the prevailing exchange rate).”

Kalila Aguilos, TAG president, told the Inquirer that the funds from equity dues being imposed by the BI are “to be divided equally among different artists groups and are to be appropriated for (their) health care.”

“Now why would the BI want to deprive artists of that? I find it so immoral,” she said.

The BI for its part said that TAG was not yet part of the MOA.

Aguilos countered that this was because of the numerous paperwork being required by BI. “It’s as if TAG’s integration is being stalled,” she noted.

Displaced

According to Pangan, the fact remains that Filipino artists are being displaced by these international  productions.

For instance, he said “Nine” will run at the same time as “Phantom.” “Nine” will go onstage at the Carlos P. Romulo Auditorium, RCBC Plaza, Makati from Sept. 21 to Oct. 7.

“But we have fewer performances compared to ‘Phantom,’” he said.

He could only hope that Filipino audiences would be more supportive of local productions.

He observed that local theater companies couldn’t mount a play without paying royalties (performance rights license), which could be pretty steep for a Tony-winning musical like “Nine.”

“Then you have to pay the actors and the crew,” he added. “You cannot scrimp on the crew because they are the most hard-working people in this business.”

Pangan considers himself fortunate that, apart from being a stage actor, he also gets gigs as frontman of the rock band The Dawn.

“We will go on tour next year. It’s pretty strange that a lot of local artists now go abroad to perform since there are more work opportunities there,” he noted. “While in our own country, foreign artists are much more in demand. It doesn’t make sense.”

He expressed optimism that the construction of Bay City—a Las Vegas-style entertainment center on reclaimed land along Roxas Boulevard, would spell good news for local artists.

“I can’t wait for that entertainment center to be finished … that would be our Broadway,” he said.

E-mail bayanisandiegojr@gmail.com


Follow Us


Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Carla Guevara-Laforteza , Cherie Gil , Jett Pangan , Menchu Lauchengco-Yulo , Phantom of the Opera , Sitti Navarro , “Nine”

  • rolandtr

    What? Is this being levied in other countries? Or just a myopic protectionist demand from local artist?

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Anton-Dans/1282066866 Anton Dans

       Taxes are levied to ALL foreign performers in the US and other countries. I’ve been part of Filipino concerts in the US, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. It’s practiced everywhere, and for the same reasons that Mr. Pangan have stated. In the US you have to pay taxes for every musician you bring, and their justification is that local musicians in the US lose out on work. They use the word displacement for that very same concept. Most producers in the US are kind enough to absorb this additional taxation as part of the costs for bringing in foreign acts.

      What makes this all really sad is that these foreign acts are familiar with the process, and are more than willing to pay these levies and taxes. Why is it that I see Filipinos fighting for their side instead of ours. This is not extortion. This is standard practice in almost every part of the world.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/VYKKARVE6D75V555LY6PEGLLUA TV

    Is this part of Cherrie Gil’s MOGADON induced deppression. Grow up, PROBLEM CHILD. You are not a diva anymore! You act the same. You sound the same. You are nothing but a secnd rate trying hard of yourself!

  • BELTAINE

    The artist groups, BI & other agencies involved should get their acts together to ensure the pro-active efficient implementation of the governing MOA. This reactive action among us Filipinos negates our international image & respect from foreigners. The foreign artists have strong guild in their country, not to mention their well-placed applicable laws, which ensure the appropriate protection of their welfare. I emphatize with our local artists on this issue, but I wish they will refrain from sounding off this kind of complaint after the foreign artists are done with their show in our country. Time to seriously sit down with BI and settle all issues/concerns once & for all.

    • kalilaaguilos

      Thank you for your objectivity. The problem is that the BOI refuses to meet with us and is in fact ignoring all calls and pleas. We have been writing, texting and calling them since February, since our last meeting with them. We are left with no other recourse but to indulge the inquiry of the press on the matter. All we want is for them to communicate with us. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GURBWYA3AIXC22EF6E6HIHRNQE Ornbort Vortingeresdemesus

    it was just stated that foreign artists are more popular here and local artists are more popular abroad. so what does not make sense? still, pay up Phantom, you’re not as good as Mr. Karimloo.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WWZMSQ4Z74QJUPXFOMEKD6KKFM kronos

    The Phantom production must have a very powerful backer that they are given privilege to be exempted from paying dues.  A musical requires performers to audition by dancing and singing.  They are not singers daw.  Ginagawa lang na mga tanga ang mga local artists narin because they can’t do anything.  It just shows how stupid our Bureau of Immigration (BI) can be.

  • http://twitter.com/MontoGawe Monto Gawe

    Galingan niyo na lang.  Wag ng gamitin ang ibang isyu para mapansin kayo.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/RTQRGKHFGLKSSJAK5J5PLOXAQQ Halo

    What an idiot bunch of local artists. Instead of coming up with original songs and songs that are relevant to the times, they insist on singing the same old crap, theyre singing from decades past. They call them remakes then now its called covers. The term has change but the same crappy songs remain.  Now they want to charge foreign artists higher fees so that they can just relax and enjoy the fruits of other people’s labor. Charging higher fees will not dampen local audience desire for better entertainment but it would certainly hurt their pockets more because the additional fees charged will have to go to the mouth of the local lazy artists.

    Our concert tickets are much much higher than compare to our neighboring countries due to higher taxas and other fees and that is totally unacceptable.

    To the local artists, please come up with something fresh, something new, something the audience wants to hear.  The days of ballads are over. The local rock bands are crap, theyre dont only sound horrible but its targetting the lower masses with their noise (sorry i dont want to call them music)  Why cant the local artists come up with a plan to re-imagine the local music industry, something what the koreans did decades ago. Decades ago K-pop is a mere copy of J-pop but look at where K-pop is now.  Personally i dont like K-pop songs but so far their songs are globally acceptable. It didnt only made global stars out of k-pop artists but it placed south korea on the global map. Now people not only want to listen to k-pop but theyre interested in everything korea as well.  Saka k-pop artists arent selfish unlike local artists. Puro pansariling bulsa lamang ang iniisp. Laos na kayo, time for re-invention.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Anton-Dans/1282066866 Anton Dans

      I have been touring with Filipino acts as part of their production crew for the past 6 years. I’ve been to New Zealand, Australia, US, Canada, and Hongkong.

       Levy and taxation and equity is standard practice everywhere else in the world. If you bring a concert to the US, you will pay musicians guilds, production unions, etc. because of jobs that Americans supposedly lose. It’s standard. Most producers in the US are also kind enough to absorb part or all of the taxation as part of the costs of producing a concert.

      It’s standard practice and these foreigners are more than willing to pay these taxes. They’re use to it. Why are so many Filipinos fighting on the side of the foreigners when the foreigners didn’t even ask for it?

  • valsore

    Ang maskulado ng mga legs nila.  Are really girls?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Krizz-Ibarra/100000181696874 Krizz Ibarra

    i don’t see how they can match andrew lloyd weber.  it’s becoming a “if you can’t beat them, tax them” to discourage the quality productions from performing locally and being enjoyed by the pinoys. baka madiskubre na maraming local “artist” na no good.

  • elvisaya

    boring naman panoorin ung mga local plays dito sa atin kung di ka antokin maasar ka lang kase sobrang O.A,….papansin lang yan para ma promote yan bagong palabas nila



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94