Quantcast
Latest Stories

Dispute erupts in national film fest

By

MARTHA Nikko Comia as Malan FDCP.COM

DAVAO City—“Malan,” a film that pays tribute to the B’laan tribe of Mindanao, was  pulled out from the ongoing 2012 Sineng Pambansa National Film Festival here on Saturday “pending settlement of dispute” between its director Benji Garcia and producer Buhilaman Visions Davao.

The Film Development Council of the Philippines (FDCP) is exerting all efforts to bring together the contending parties in the dispute so that they can amicably settle their differences regarding creative rights and artistic credits arising from the making of the film.

Garcia said he was pleased with the FDCP’s move to pull out the “producer’s cut” of “Malan” from the festival, which will culminate on July 3.

“I think they made the right decision. This was something they should have

done a month ago,” the director told the Inquirer.

Garcia, however, stressed that he has no more intention of sitting down with the producers to discuss the issue. “I already lost my trust in them. They have proven to be liars and thieves. I’ll just discuss with the FDCP my intention of having the film join other festivals here or abroad,” he added.

Producer Malou Tiangco said her group was willing to talk with Garcia to fix the problem.

Members of the B’laan tribe reportedly protested some scenes in the movie, particularly the “torrid” kissing performed by actors Glenn Antaran (Anton) and Martha Nikko Comia (Malan).

Claiming artistic rights to the film, Garcia reportedly refused to have the contested scenes removed. This allegedly prompted the production team to make a “producer’s cut” that was shown during the first day of the five-day festival.

Set in 1967, “Malan” is the story of Anton, who takes a break from his stressful work in Manila to visit his uncle in Polomolok, South Cotabato. This is where he meets and falls in love with a B’laan girl named Malan, who is already betrothed to be the second wife or “dowoya” of Sengko, a native B’laan tribesman half her age.

Their romance becomes a huge controversy that has to be resolved by a tribal council. Before Anton can do something about the situation, Malan is whisked off to the faraway Bulul Mala, also a community of B’laan people.

“Malan” is one of 18 films—full-length features, documentaries and animated shorts— selected from the FDCP-initiated National Film Competition held last year. The finalists were awarded seed money to finish their movies.

At press time, Garcia and Tiangco have reached a compromise agreement, in which both director’s cut and producer’s cut will be screened at the fest.


Follow Us


Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Entertainment , Movies , news , “Malan”

  • dequis

    pag sinabing “indie” ibig bang sabihin nyan maliliit na mangagawa ng pelikula. di dapat walang mga malalaking artistang katulad ng mga nora aunor o vilma santos. doon na lang kumuha ng actors at actresses sa mga dramatic guild ng mga kolehiyo. at saka huwag paulit ulit ang mukha at mga ordinaryong mukha lang ang pagaganapin sa mga penikulang ganyan.

    • http://jaoromero.com/ Jao Romero

      ibig sabihin lang ng “indie” ay “independent,” na ang ibig sabihin lamang ay walang malaking production company ang nasa likod ng paggawa ng pelikula. karaniwan ng kaakibat ng indie ang maliit na budget o minsa’y walang regular na pondo. kaya sya tinawag na indie ay dahil ginawa ang pelikula “independent from any film studio.”

      kaya karaniwan nang ang mga aktor at aktres na gumaganap dito ay yung mga di kilala, dahil walang kakayahan ang mga gumagawa ng pelikula na magbayad ng mga kilalang pangalan. pero hindi ibig sabihin na di na pwedeng ganapan ng mga sikat na artista ang isang indie film. hindi nito ibig sabihin na kapag ginanapan na ng sikat na artista ang isang pelikula ay di na ito matatawag na “indie.”

      ang nakakahiya ay yung mga production companies na dummies ng malalaking film studios na nagpapanggap na gumagawa ng indies para makisawsaw pa sa market na ito. ang nakakahiya ay ang mga batikang direktor na sumasawsaw pa sa indies samantalang dapat pinauubaya na nila ito sa bagong dugo.

      ang tunay na lapastangan ay ang isang pelikulang itinulak ng may malaking budget na mag panggap na isang indie para lamang pumasok sa isang festival. itinulak ng batikang producer, dinirek ng batikang direktor, ginanapan ng mga batikang aktor, at mismong ang crew ay lahat matagal na sa industriya.

      para kang matanda na nakisali sa larong bata.

      • dequis

        di ko na binasa ng buo ang sagot mo ha pre ha, ang haba kasi. mamaya babalikan ko rin ang sinabi mo. wala naman talaga akong tiyak na kaalaman sa mga ndieindie kaya patanong ang salita ko sa comment ko. kaya ko lang binasa ang balita dahil sumusulat din ako ng dula. ang pinansin ko lang muna ay iyong huli mong sentence. ikaw pala’y mahilig magsalita ng masama sa kapwa, ano?

      • http://jaoromero.com/ Jao Romero

        basahin mo muna pre para maintindihan mo. di mo babasahin ng buo tapos magsasabi ka ng kung ano-ano. e di napahiya ka sa mali mong akala. pakisabi nga kung anong masama ang sinabi ko.

      • dequis

        di mo alam alin sa sinabi mo ang masama, ganoon? sabagay, baka gawain mo na talaga ang magsalita ng masama sa kapwa kung ksys parang natural na lang sa’yo ang magsalita ng masama.

      • http://jaoromero.com/ Jao Romero

        well, tukuyin mo nga para malaman ko, hindi yung dada ka dyan ng dada.

      • dequis

        baka kelangan mo to p’re, si Will Durant ang may sabi: To speak ill of others is a dishonest way of praising ourselves.

  • BuffyDSlayer

    im saddened by the fact that Garcia the director would rather violate the sensibilities of the tribe he portrays to give way to his “Artistic” concepts…prinotesta ng tribo ang ginawa mong torrid scenes bec it goes against what they considers proper…dapat iginalng mo yon as an artisit. art imitates life d ba? so you can’t get away with just portraying anything bec in life there are rules of respect and dignity and social mores… mas gusto mo pa Mr Garcia na makipagaway sa tribong pinoportray mo at sa mga producers kesa pakingggan an protesta nila…do you think magkakarun ka ng pelikula kung nd sila pumayag na kunan mo sila at gawan ng istorya? ganun ka ba ka narrow-minded?



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94