Court rules Batmobile is entitled to copyright protection
In this June 27, 1989 file photo, the original Batman, Adam West, left, stands beside the old Batmobile driven by owner Scott Chinery in Philadelphia. Batman won’t have to worry about Batmobile knockoffs after a federal appeals court ruled the caped crusader’s vehicle is entitled to copyright protection. The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals said Wednesday, Sept. 23, 2015, the Batmobile’s bat-like appearance and other distinct traits make it a character that can’t be replicated without permission from DC Comics, the copyright holder. AP FILE PHOTO
SAN FRANCISCO — Batman won’t have to worry about Batmobile knockoffs after a federal appeals court ruled Wednesday the caped crusader’s vehicle is entitled to copyright protection.
The Batmobile’s bat-like appearance and other distinct attributes, including its high-tech weaponry, make it a character that can’t be replicated without permission from DC Comics, the copyright holder, the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals said.
“As Batman so sagely told Robin, ‘In our well-ordered society, protection of private property is essential,'” Judge Sandra Ikuta wrote for the three-judge panel.
Among the Batmobile’s traits she cited in her ruling was its sleekness and power, which allow Batman to maneuver quickly while he goes after bad guys.
The ruling came in DC Comics’ lawsuit against Mark Towle, who produced replicas of the Batmobile as it appeared in the 1966 television show featuring Adam West as Batman and the 1989 movie with Michael Keaton in the lead role.
The 9th Circuit said Towle sold the cars at his Southern California business for about $90,000 each.
Larry Zerner, an attorney for Towle, said his client copied the car’s design, which can’t be copyrighted.
“Characters exist in comic books and movies and TV shows,” he said. “They don’t exist in the real world. In the real world, it’s just a car.”
In its ruling, the 9th Circuit said Towle advertised each replica as the “Batmobile,” and used the domain name batmobilereplicas.com to market his business. He also advertised that the replicas would get noticed because of the Batmobile’s fame, the court said.
Towle also argued the Batmobile at times appeared without its “bat-like” features. But the 9th Circuit said that was akin to James Bond changing from swimming trunks to a tuxedo: It didn’t alter the car’s innate characteristics.
