Miley Cyrus gets more than she bargained for


CYRUS. The critiques may be pungent, but they’re well-meant.

It looks like Miley Cyrus got more than she bargained for when she recently “killed” her original show biz persona, “sweet” Hannah Montana, by “shamelessly” stripping and “twerking” at the MTV awards rites last month.

Yes, her “sexy” moves heated up her image and boosted the annual video music rites’ ratings by some 60 percent. —But, they also resulted in a veritable storm and flood of protests from many concerned and even shocked people, including parents and teachers who worried that young Miley was setting a bad example for other youths.

Even more disturbingly for the beleaguered star, some of her critics were show biz personalities like her, who feared, not just for her stellar future, but also for her personal equanimity and cohesive self-image.

Most recently, the once similarly controversial Sinead O’Connor tried to knock some sense into Miley’s head by pointing out that she didn’t have to play the entertainment industry’s “willing prostitute” game, just to spice up her prospects as a young-adult performer.

Other celebrities added that stars have been serially transforming their performing image for a long time now, like Madonna and Cher’s periodic “reincarnations.” But, the difference in Miley’s case is that she’s done it ineptly, merely for shock value’s sake.


At least, when Madonna periodically reinvents herself, she does so with artistry and panache—not just by stripping and “twerking” all over the place!

Naturally, some of Miley’s celebrity critics’ barbed comments haven’t sat well with her, her fans and her determinedly supportive parents. But, they should realize that the critiques may be pungent, but they’re well-meant—intended not to shame the young star, but to arrest her free-fall into utter notoriety—and premature disrepute!

Her career may temporarily benefit from the attendant controversy, but if she loses more fans than gain new admirers, it could prove self-destructive in the long term.

Sizzling examples

In addition, they should realize that Miley is getting off relatively easily, compared to other stars who, through the years and decades, have been savaged much more cattily and bitchily by their cofelines and bitches in the biz! Some sizzling examples:

Carol Channing: The only time in my life I ever got sick was when I watched Barbra Streisand in “Hello, Dolly!”

Bette Davis on Joan Crawford: She was Hollywood’s first case of galloping syphilis! I wouldn’t sit on her toilet.

Simone Signoret: Brigette Bardot was a sex symbol—period. When she lost her looks, she lost everything. —Including her mind!

Gina Lollobrigida: Sophia Loren plays peasants—I play ladies!

Louise Brooks: Lillian Gish was a sexless, silly antique!

Elsa Lanchester: Maggie Smith is better seen onstage, from a distance. On a movie screen, up close, she makes you want to dive for cover!

Minnie Ripperton: Olivia Newton-John is Australia’s gift to insomniacs—she’s nothing but the blonde singing the bland!

Katharine Hepburn on Sharon Stone: It’s a new low for actresses when you have to wonder what’s between her legs—instead of her ears!

So, Miley is getting off relatively easily? —You bet!

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.


    Nestor U. Torre has no idea what they are talking about. It was all carefully staged and Miley has shot to the top of the Billboard and UK charts as a result. She has had more than one smash hit from her album and there are NO signs of her popularity fading.

    To make a negative comparison with Madonna, who according to this writer acted with ‘artistry and panache’ displays a remarkable ignorance of the facts, for Madonna has regularly courted controversy, including posing nude, and challenging Catholic symbolism to such an extent she has been accused of blasphemy. The reason for it all? Publicity, exactly the same as Miley, and one thing you can be absolutely certain of, the Material Girl would have been twerking too, had it been around in the early 80’s.

    • fredrique

      the writer is stuck in a time warp.. forgive him for he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.. next!

  • Iggy Ramirez

    When Madonna “broke” the rules at the time, it was considered abominable. Everyone wanted their children as far away from her as possible.

    Now that the bar has been set there, Miley had no choice but to up the ante. Otherwise, she would only be known as a Madonna copycat.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos